Newnan, GA vs Peachtree City: Why Newnan Is the Smarter Move
If you’re planning a move out of metro Atlanta and want a community with small-town charm, affordability, and strong schools, two names stand out — Newnan, GA and Peachtree City, GA. Both are among the most desirable suburbs south of Atlanta.
However, when you compare lifestyle, cost, and opportunity side by side, Newnan consistently offers more value for families and professionals. This detailed guide breaks down real numbers — from home prices and schools to commute and amenities — to show why Newnan stands above Peachtree City in 2025.
Home Prices and Real Estate Value
Peachtree City’s median home price sits around $565,000, reflecting its established reputation and mature neighborhoods. In comparison, the median home price in Newnan is approximately $349,000, offering buyers far more space, newer construction, and larger lots for significantly less money.
In Newnan, you’ll find everything from affordable homes under $400,000 to luxury estates in gated communities such as SummerGrove, Lake Redwine, and Stonebridge. Coweta County’s lower property taxes further enhance Newnan’s affordability compared to Fayette County.
Simply put, Newnan delivers more home for your money, stronger appreciation potential as growth continues, and lower long-term costs — making it an ideal choice for smart real estate investment.
Commute and Location Advantages
When it comes to location, Newnan offers excellent accessibility. The city sits roughly 38 to 40 miles from downtown Atlanta, with an average commute of about 45 minutes during standard traffic. Peachtree City, located about 34 miles away, averages around 40 minutes. The difference in drive time is minimal, yet the difference in housing costs is substantial.
Newnan’s direct access to Interstate 85 makes commuting straightforward, providing quick routes to Atlanta, Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport, and major employers throughout the region.
Residents also enjoy the flexibility of being only 15 minutes from Peachtree City, meaning they can easily access its shopping, golf courses, and dining options without paying higher home prices.
With its affordability, growing infrastructure, and central access, Newnan delivers unmatched convenience and value.
Schools and Family-Friendly Living
Newnan families benefit from the highly regarded Coweta County School System, which includes respected campuses such as Newnan High, East Coweta High, and Brooks Elementary. These schools are known for strong academics, athletics, and extracurricular programs.
While Peachtree City’s Fayette County schools remain some of the best in Georgia, home prices within those districts are significantly higher. Families relocating to Newnan often discover they can purchase larger homes in equally strong school zones, balancing educational quality with financial flexibility.
Neighborhoods like SummerGrove, Heritage Ridge, and Stonebridge provide a family-oriented environment, active HOA communities, and excellent access to parks, recreation, and local events.
Newnan’s combination of affordable housing and quality education creates a perfect setting for families looking to settle in a thriving community.
Lifestyle, Amenities, and Community Feel
Downtown Newnan blends history, culture, and modern living. With restored architecture, boutique shops, local dining, and a full calendar of festivals and events, it offers a warm, connected community atmosphere.
The city’s continued growth has brought major retail centers, medical facilities, and recreational amenities, including Ashley Park, Chattahoochee Bend State Park, and Carl Miller Park.
While Peachtree City is famous for its golf cart paths and established neighborhoods, many of its homes and infrastructure are older and require higher maintenance. In contrast, Newnan continues to expand with newer developments, modern design, and a forward-looking community plan that fits today’s lifestyles.
Residents in Newnan enjoy the charm of a historic Southern town combined with all the conveniences of a modern, growing city.
Cost of Living and Economic Growth
The overall cost of living in Newnan is approximately 10 to 15 percent lower than in Peachtree City, driven primarily by lower housing and tax costs. Coweta County continues to attract new employers, healthcare providers, and logistics companies, boosting local job opportunities and stabilizing home values.
Economic development projects around Newnan Crossing and Ashley Park have created an expanding mix of dining, retail, and entertainment options that rival larger suburbs.
With steady population growth, expanding infrastructure, and continued investment, Newnan offers a strong real estate appreciation outlook and remains one of the most desirable communities south of Atlanta.
Community Testimonials
“The commute to Atlanta is quick, the schools are great, and we love the small-town charm. We looked at Peachtree City, but Newnan offered everything we wanted for less.”
— Homebuyer relocating from Smyrna, GA
“We found a newer home with more space in Newnan for $150,000 less than Peachtree City. It was an easy decision.”
— Recent SummerGrove resident
These experiences reflect what many homebuyers find: Newnan delivers a superior quality of life and better long-term value than neighboring suburbs.
Why Newnan Tops Peachtree City in 2025
Across every major category, Newnan stands out as the smarter move for today’s buyers. Home prices are lower, property taxes are more affordable, and families can access excellent schools and modern amenities without paying premium prices. The commute to Atlanta is comparable, and Newnan’s ongoing growth continues to strengthen its economy and housing market.
Peachtree City remains an attractive and established suburb, but for most families, professionals, and first-time buyers, Newnan provides the same convenience and quality of life at a significantly lower cost.
Conclusion
When you weigh the numbers, lifestyle, and long-term potential, Newnan, GA offers more home, more community, and more opportunity for your money. Families relocating from Atlanta or comparing southern suburbs consistently find Newnan to be the best balance of value, location, and quality of life.
If you’re ready to explore homes in Newnan or want expert guidance on finding the right neighborhood, trust the Tim Stout Group with eXp Realty. Our team specializes in helping buyers and sellers navigate the Newnan market with confidence and results.
Contact us today to find your dream home in Newnan, Georgia — where value meets lifestyle.
References
Zillow Home Values: Peachtree City and Newnan, GA (2025 data snapshot)
Travelmath.com – Driving Distances and Commute Estimates
Coweta County School System – School Rankings and District Overview
Newnan City Economic Development Reports, 2024–2025
Property Focus – Median Home Prices and Market Trends for Newnan, GA
U.S. Census Bureau – Cost of Living Index, 2024 Estimates
